Rare Squishmallows That Are Very Valuable

Some rare Squishmallows are worth hundreds or even thousands. These are the most valuable and rare Squishmallows.

Squishmallows have taken the world by storm. With over 1,000 Squishmallow characters, each has their own name, personality and storyline.

Children love the comforting, soft texture of the adorable stuffed animals, while adults have uncomfortable flashbacks of the Beanie Baby craze of the late 1990s. Like Beanie Babies, some Squishmallows are rarer and more desirable than others.

The appeal can be because they’re extra cute, part of a unique set, or haven’t been produced a lot. Whatever the reason, rare Squishmallows can command high prices.

26. Lucille the Seal

Lucille the Seal is a rare Squishmallow

Released: Sealife

Price: $69.95

Bottom Line: Lucille the Seal

Lucille the Seal Squishmallow

Lucille the Seal is a small, white Squishmallow released as part of the Sealife Squad in 2020.

Beloved for her chubby appearances and quirky character traits (she loves rocks and gems), Lucille is primarily rare because there have only been four seal Squishmallows produced in total.

25. Louisa the Penguin

Louisa the Penguin Squishmallow

Squad: None

Price: $69.99

Bottom Line: Louisa the Penguin

Louisa the Penguin Squishmallow Photo

Louisa is an adorable little tie-dye penguin who loves skiing.

There’s also a special Purple Louisa version in which her yellow is replaced by purple. The color shift increases the rarity of this Squishmallow and makes it a valuable collectible.

Many Squishmallows have their rarity based not only on color but also on size.

24. Lenora the Loon

Rare Lenora the Loon Squishmallow

Squishmallows / eBay

Squad: None

Price: $75

Bottom Line: Lenora the Loon

Lenora the Loon Squishmallow

Lenora is a black and gray Squishmallow that is primarily rare due to her exclusivity in Canada.

She can’t sing but wants to start a rock band, which may be a bit of a challenge. That’s because he’s completely tone-deaf. We guess someone wasn’t very fond of loons.

In fact, many of the rarest Squishmallows are only available in Canada.

23. Daxxon the Purple Alien

Squishmallow: Daxxon the Purple Alien

Squad: Space

Price: $79

Bottom Line: Daxxon the Purple Alien

Daxxon the Purple Alien Squishmallow

This fun little purple alien is also quite rare. Part of the Space Squad, Daxxon was released in 2020 and is featured in two sizes: 8 inches and 16 inches.

Daxxon is sought-after not only because he’s part of the rare Space Squad but also because he’s adorable.

22. Celine the Hen

Celine the Hen Rare Squishmallow

Squad: Farm

Price: $149

Bottom Line: Celine the Hen

Celine the Hen, collectible Squishmallow

Celine’s a light brown Squishmallow whose aunt works for a nonprofit. Huh. These Squishmallows lead really interesting and oddly specific lives.

When Celine grows up, she also wants to work for a nonprofit organization helping the world. A great goal for a small chicken.

21. Avery the Duck

Avery the Duck collectible Squishmallow

Squad: Adventure, Farm

Price: $180

Bottom Line: Avery the Duck

Avery the Duck Squishmallows

Avery is a rare duck that is part of two squads: Adventure and Farm. He’s also available in six sizes, making him further rare. Most are only available in one or two.

He loves rugby, wants to be a coach, and spends his spare time stacked in the pillows on a small child’s bed.

20. Connor the Cow

Connor the Cow Rare Squishmallow

Squad: Farm

Price: $200

Bottom Line: Connor the Cow

Connor the Cow Squishmallow

A fun, large Squishmallow, Connor the Cow is partly unique for his availability in the Jumbo size.

This 24-inch Squishmallow can command a couple of hundred dollars and is often sold in bundles as a family with the Mom and Baby Connor Squishmallow.

There are a lot of cow Squishmallows out there/ Consider collecting the entire crew.

19. Mariah the Lamb

Mariah the Lamb

Squad: Baby

Price: $200

Bottom Line: Mariah the Lamb

Mariah the Lamb

Squishmallows / Reddit

Mariah the Lamb loves horseback riding and horchata, which may give one the idea that perhaps someone is just playing mad libs with these Squishmallows.

She was a rare Aldi store exclusive.

18. Stix the Skeleton

Stix the Skeleton

Squad: Halloween

Price: $329

Bottom Line: Stix the Skeleton

Stix the Skeleton

This adorable little skeleton is rare and unique because it was only produced as a Halloween Squishmallow.

It features a black body with a small skeleton outline.

17. Chanel the Cinnamon Roll

Chanel the Cinnamon Roll

Squad: Valentine

Price: $349

Bottom Line: Chanel the Cinnamon Roll

Chanel the Cinnamon Roll

This adorable pastry likes cooking, which raises some serious questions about the fundamentals of the Squishmallow world.

She’s rare because she was only released during the Valentine Squad event in 2020.

16. Patty the Cow

Patty the Cow

Squad: Easter

Price: $350

Bottom Line: Patty the Cow

Patty the Cow

An Easter release, Patty the Cow is a popular little cow that loves to help out at the Farmer’s Market.

Like many rare Squishmallows, Patty the Cow doesn’t have widespread production but was instead released for a holiday.

15. Philippe the Frog

Philippe the Frog

Squad: Valentine

Price: $350

Bottom Line: Philippe the Frog

Philippe the Frog

One of the Valentine’s Day exclusives, Philippe the Frog loves to hang out with his friends and play hopscotch.

Since he was a promotional Squishmallow, he’s rarer than others. He was only produced for Valentine’s Day 2020.

14. Stacy the Squid

Stacy the Squid

Squad: Sealife, Valentine

Price: $401

Bottom Line: Stacy the Squid

Stacy the Squid

A beautiful blue Squishmallow (Squidmallow?), Stacy is noted as being incredibly shy. She loves to learn, read books, and hang out with her friends.

Part of both the Adventure and Valentine squads, Stacy is notably unique because she is only produced for Valentine’s Day.

13. Gordon the Shark

Gordon the Shark

Squad: Sealife

Price: $420

Bottom Line: Gordon the Shark

Gordon the Shark

One of the rare Sealife releases, Gordon the Shark is released as both a regular Squishmallow and a stackable.

He’s a friendly Squishmallow who also wants to start a nonprofit, which appears to be a trend among the Squishmallows.

12. Bernice the Boba

Bernice the Boba

Squad: Exclusive

Price: $489

Bottom Line: Bernice the Boba

Bernice the Boba

Bernice the Boba is described as being blissful, bubbly, and bright, which is no small feat for a food product meant to be consumed.

Bernice the Boba is another Canadian exclusive, making her much rarer than other Squishmallows.

11. Bigfoot

Bigfoot

Squad: Exclusive

Price: $522

Bottom Line: Bigfoot

Bigfoot

Bigfoot was a Canadian Superstore exclusive, making it another extremely rare and popular Squishmallow.

There are actually several varieties of Bigfoot, with the white, fluffy version being the rarest.

You can also find Benny, Zaylee and Caparinne.

10. Blossom the Sheep

Blossom the Sheep

Squad: Justice

Price: $575

Bottom Line: Blossom the Sheep

Blossom the Sheep

A limited release, rare and exclusive Squishmallow, Blossom the Sheep was released in collaboration with Justice and was available in Canada.

This is a special sheep that will never be produced again.

9. Claire the Cow

Claire the Cow

Squad: Farm

Price: $600

Bottom Line: Claire the Cow

Claire the Cow

Squishmallows / Reddit

Claire is a 2020 release of a purple and pink 12-inch stackable cow, with the stackables themselves being a very popular line.

She loves sunrises, clover and bananas on toast. Just as most cows do.

8. Santino the Platypus

Santino the Platypus

Squad: None

Price: $625

Bottom Line: Santino the Platypus

Santino the Platypus

Who doesn’t love a good platypus? Santino is a little brown Squishmallow that comes in 2 inches or 12 inches. Without any arms and with a tiny little nose, he’s as close to a pillow as a Squishmallow is apt to be.

One of the most expensive and rare Squishmallows in existence, Santino loves soccer and makes great pancakes. Which is impressive, since again, he doesn’t have any arms.

Part of the rarity involves his color. Most Squishmallows are unnatural colors. Santino is one of the few that is brown.

7. Heather the Dragonfly

Heather the Dragonfly

Squad: None

Price: $914

Bottom Line: Heather the Dragonfly

Heather the Dragonfly

The 16-inch size of Heather the Dragonfly is extremely rare and expensive. This Squishmallow was a Canada exclusive, which also makes it rare.

Heather is known to be a particularly positive Squishmallow who embraces change.

6. Ben the Teal Dino

Ben the Teal Dino

Squad: Dream, Fantasy

Price: $1,000

Bottom Line: Ben the Teal Dino

Ben the Teal Dino

This blue, green dinosaur has a white belly and plenty of love to give.

He’s also a trivia expert who can tackle nearly any topic you question him on. To have him on your team will cost you, however. He recently sold for $1,000 at auction.

5. Beatrice the Lamb

Beatrice the Lamb

Squad: Easter

Price: $1,200

Bottom Line: Beatrice the Lamb

Beatrice the Lamb

Squee! This adorable purple lamb is just 3.5 inches tall and has a handle so you can dangle her from just about anywhere.

She can be pricey, but her value has a range from a little over $200 to $1200, which is what she sold for on eBay in May 2022.

4. Jack the Black Cat

Jack the Black Cat

Squad: Select Series

Price: $1,200

Bottom Line: Jack the Black Cat

Jack the Black Cat

Squishmallows / WorthPoint

The rarest Squishmallow in the world is likely Jack the Black Cat. Jack was part of the Select Series of Squishmallows, and there were very few produced.

Jack is also the 500th Squishmallows character produced, which makes him doubly unique.

Related: Most Valuable Beanie Babies

3. Fania the Purple Owl

Fania the Purple Owl

Squad: None

Price: $2,999

Bottom Line: Fania the Purple Owl

Fania the Purple Owl

Fania is the only Squishmallow with closed eyes, which is because she’s a sleepy owl who loves to drift off to fairy tales.

While that doesn’t make her rare in itself, this 11-inch Target exclusive is one harder-to-find versions of her.

2. Golden Hans the Hedgehog

Golden Hans the Hedgehog

Squad: Original

Price: $15,000

Bottom Line: Golden Hans the Hedgehog

Golden Hans the Hedgehog

There were only 25 24-inch Golden Hans toys ever made, and these were meant to be awarded to competition winners. One of them is the 100 millionth Squishmallow ever sold.

To commemorate this, the particular toy has a special tag in its ear, with Jonathan Kelly’s (the CEO of Kellytoys) signature. The proceeds from this auction went to an art nonprofit, Art in Action.

1. Fifi the Fox Family

Fifi the Fox Family

Squad: Heroes

Price: $17,999

Bottom Line: Fifi the Fox Family

Fifi the Fox Family

Fifi made her debut in 2017 and can be found in a variety of different sizes. As a solo Squish, she’s fairly common, but according to one seller, she’s a rare a find when she has her family in tow.

An eBayer is selling three Fifi toys as single collection with an 8-inch, 16-inch and 20-inch model, which they refer to as “mom, dad, and baby.”

×