Most Valuable Carnival Glass Antiques

Most carnival glass is worth a few hundred dollars. But the rarest and most valuable pieces are worth thousands.

Exactly what is carnival glass? You’ve likely seen it (or maybe even collected it) and not realized it. Carnival glass is a specific type of pressed glass that has an oil-like sheen to its surface. Popular in the 1920s, it’s still collected today.

Carnival glass started as a low-end imitation of more expensive glass-blowing techniques. Then it became a collectible itself. Most antique carnival glass is worth a few hundred dollars. But the rarest pieces are worth thousands.

25. Northwood Electric Blue Carnival Bowl

Northwood Electric Blue Carnival Bowl

Live Auctioneers

Sold: April 22, 2012

Value: $1,400

Bottom Line: Northwood Electric Blue Carnival Bowl

Electric blue valuable carnival glass

Live Auctioneers

A brilliant bowl with a scalloped edge and matte glaze, this bowl is designed to be reminiscent of a wicker basket filled with flowers.

This is an excellent example of Northwood’s aesthetic and the “electric blue” color, just slightly brighter than dark cobalt.

24. Imperial Electric Purple Carnival Glass Plate

Imperial Electric Purple Carnival Glass Plate

Live Auctioneers

Sold: July 30, 2005

Value: $1,500

Bottom Line: Imperial Electric Purple Carnival Glass Plate

Back of valuable glass bowl

Live Auctioneers

Not all carnival glass was made by Millersburg, Northwood, or Fenton. Imperial made this electric purple plate.

It has an extraordinarily unique design: a pastoral setting with a classically influenced border.

23. Millersburg Elk’s Bowl

Millersburg Elk's Bowl

Live Auctioneers

Sold: May 21, 2020

Value: $1,600

Bottom Line: Millersburg Elk’s Bowl

Elk's bowl closeup

Live Auctioneers

Oranges and yellows were a little more difficult to create back when carnival glass was first made, so this fiery plate is already quite rare.

Inset into the transparent plate is a noble elk (hence “Elk’s Bowl”) surrounded by leaves and branches.

22. Gerurtz Brother’s Furniture

Gerurtz Brother's Furniture

Live Auctioneers

Sold: May 21, 2020

Value: $1,700

Bottom Line: Gerurtz Brother’s Furniture

Carnival glass zoomed in

Live Auctioneers

This is a piece of collectible ephemera. The carnival glass plate reads “Gerurtz Brother’s Furniture & Clothing. Union Ave & East Burnside.”

The piece is a treasured collectible for those who love carnival glass and advertising alike.

21. Dugan Carnival Glass Christmas Compote

Dugan Carnival Glass Christmas Compote

Live Auctioneers

Sold: Oct. 2, 2015

Value: $1,700

Bottom Line: Dugan Carnival Glass Christmas Compote

Front view of dugan carnival glass

Live Auctioneers

An incredibly ornate and deeply colored amethyst glass, this rare pattern is difficult to find.

Little berries, leaves and stems are strewn all along the chalice, which stands at around 10 inches high.

20. Northwood Tree Trunk Funeral Vase

Northwood Tree Trunk Funeral Vase

Live Auctioneers

Sold: Oct. 02, 2015

Value: $1,900

Bottom Line: Northwood Tree Trunk Funeral Vase

Funeral vase closeup

Live Auctioneers

This complex “elephant foot” vase was designed by Northwood. This particular one has a small factory flaw, or it might command more.

The entire vase is designed to be reminiscent of “bark.” Though the iridescence of carnival glass is firmly artificial, a significant portion of the designs invokes nature.

19. Dugan Butterfly and Tulip Glass Bowl

Dugan Butterfly and Tulip Glass Bowl

Live Auctioneers

Sold: April 13, 2013

Value: $1,900

Bottom Line: Dugan Butterfly and Tulip Glass Bowl

Dugan butterfly left side

Live Auctioneers

A beautiful flowing design and dark, almost chocolatey purple glass set this Dugan glass bowl off.

The bowl features a scalloped rim, four ball feet, and a feathered scroll pattern, which includes a beautiful butterfly, flower, and leaves.

18. Northwood Poppy Show Plate

Poppy plate

Live Auctioneers

Sold: Oct. 8, 2010

Value: $3,000

Bottom Line: Northwood Poppy Show Plate

Northwood poppy

Live Auctioneers

Rare due to its color and its quality, this Northwood plate is the perfect example of the “Poppy Show” mold.

The Poppy Show design was an extremely popular one that can be found in a multitude of colors. In this plate, it’s on an opal, iridescent backing, which is a particularly rare color.

17. Millersburg Blue Peacock Bowl

Millersburg Blue Peacock Bowl

Sold: 2021

Value: $4,000

Bottom Line: Millersburg Blue Peacock Bowl

Blue peacock glass

You’ll find quite a few bowls and plates in this design, with a brilliant glass finish and a picture of an animal in the center. These collectible bowls were produced by Millersburg in a variety of colors, patterns and values.

This particular bowl is in good condition with a particularly rare edging.

16. Northwood Blue Carnival Glass Corn Vase

Northwood Blue Carnival Glass Corn Vase

Sold: 2021

Value: $4,995

Bottom Line: Northwood Blue Carnival Glass Corn Vase

Bottom of blue corn vase

Here’s a very rare, blue corn vase by Northwood. In better condition, it could fetch up to $10,000.

That’s because this vase is designed with some tremendous care. Even the bottom of the vase has a flowery design.

The vase is particularly desirable because of its bright blue, cobalt color and the heaviness of its iridescence.

15. Farmyard Square Bowl

Farmyard Square Bowl

Sold: March 12, 2022

Value: $6,500

Bottom Line: Farmyard Square Bowl

Farmyard bowl

A purple iridescent square bowl, this Farmyard classic features roosters and a carefully pearled/scalloped edge.

In excellent condition, it is a rare example of the “orange, yellow, red” colors that are frequently sought-after in Carnival glass.

14. Early Blue Carnival Glass Dish

Early Blue Carnival Glass Dish

Live Auctioneers

Sold: Aug. 18, 2006

Value: $7,000

Bottom Line: Early Blue Carnival Glass Dish

Carnival glass blue dish

Live Auctioneers

A gorgeous blue Carnival glass dish with very little wear, this is an excellent example of what a good Carnival glass piece can fetch on the open market.

Color matters when it comes to Carnival glass. The rarest colors are red, yellow, purple and green. A blue plate like this would fetch much more in one of these more desirable colors.

13. Millersburg Green Peacock Bowl

Millersburg Green Peacock Bowl

Live Auctioneers

Sold: June 28, 2010

Value: $7,000

Bottom Line: Millersburg Green Peacock Bowl

green peacock bowl

Live Auctioneers

Here’s an excellent example of the stamping of these plates. Compare the Millersburg Blue Peacock Bowl to the Millersburg Green Peacock Bowl. The stamping is the same, but the appearance is dramatically different.

This shallow plate is particularly unique because of its color.

12. Kiwi Antique Amethyst Carnival Glass

Kiwi Antique Amethyst Carnival Glass

Sold: Feb. 19, 2022

Value: $7,532

Bottom Line: Kiwi Antique Amethyst Carnival Glass

Kiwi antique

A rare, early carnival glass bowl with some minor imperfections, this bowl is unique in that it displays the Australian Kiwi rather than another, more common bird.

Like other bowls, it has a decorated rim and iridescent design.

11. Dugan Marigold Tumbler

Dugan Marigold Tumbler

Sold: Pending

Value: $17,500

Bottom Line: Dugan Marigold Tumbler

Dugan marigold tumbler

A century old, this is believed to be the only Dugan Marigold Tumbler discovered. Not only is it in great condition, but it’s the only one known of this color and this style.

It is believed to have been manufactured somewhere between 1905 and 1929 and likely came in a set.

10. Millersburg Morning Glory Pitcher

Millersburg Morning Glory Pitcher

Hooked on Carnival

Sold: March 25, 2017

Value: $42,000

Bottom Line: Millersburg Morning Glory Pitcher

Millersburg morning

Hooked on Carnival

A functional pitcher designed in incredibly high, dark chrome, this Millersburg Morning Glory Pitcher is extremely desirable.

Not only is the color rare, but it’s just a very exceptional and notable piece, in part because of the strength of its colors.

9. Northwood Poppy Show Plate

Northwood Poppy Show Plate

Hooked on Carnival

Sold: Aug. 13, 2011

Value: $45,000

Bottom Line: Northwood Poppy Show Plate

Poppy show late close up

Hooked on Carnival

Beautiful and unique pastel colors set this show plate off from the rest. A blue, lightly sparkling background gives way to intricate, chromed flowers at the center.

This show plate is sure to be a showstopper in person, in part because most people would be terrified of accidentally breaking it.

8. Millersburg Hobstar and Feather Vase

Millersburg Hobstar and Feather Vase

Hooked on Carnival

Sold: Oct. 6, 2012

Value: $50,000

Bottom Line: Millersburg Hobstar and Feather Vase

Feather vase

Hooked on Carnival

Gorgeous, iridescent colors wrap this vase, which emerges as a brilliant green at the very top. If you’ve ever met a peacock, you know that these colors appear in nature.

You also probably know that peacocks are jerks. But this vase perfectly blends beauty and functionality.

There is only one known in green.

7. Millersburg Flowering Vine

Millersburg Flowering Vine

Hooked on Carnival

Sold: June 6, 2021

Value: $50,000

Bottom Line: Millersburg Flowering Vine

Flowering vine carnival glass

Hooked on Carnival

The price, $50,000, isn’t bad for a glass flower, is it? This amethyst flowering vine is designed with a sleek, symmetrical handle and a delicate flower that’s decorated with other flowers (flower-ception) at the top.

The whole thing has the beautiful chrome spectrum of carnival glass running through it.

6. Fenton Goddess of Harvest Bowl

Fenton Goddess of Harvest Bowl

Hooked on Carnival

Sold: June 13, 2014

Value: $52,500

Bottom Line: Fenton Goddess of Harvest Bowl

Harvest bowl

Hooked on Carnival

A person, in profile, looks to the left while surrounded by intricate patterns, designs and the iridescent glow of the glass.

This Harvest Bowl likely sold for quite a bit, not just because of its history but also because of its condition.

The brilliant colors of the carnival glass show just as brightly as when they were first created.

5. Cleveland Memorial Souvenir Ashtray

Cleveland Memorial Souvenir Ashtray

Hooked on Carnival

Sold: June 13, 2020

Value: $55,000

Bottom Line: Cleveland Memorial Souvenir Ashtray

Carnival glass

Hooked on Carnival

Why is a souvenir ashtray so valuable, you might ask? Actually, if you were born after 1990, you’re probably more confused as to whether a souvenir ashtray existed at all.

But when carnival glass was trendy, everyone smoked. This ashtray is particularly valuable because it’s in a rare color.

4. Northwood Tornado Vase

Northwood Tornado Vase

Hooked on Carnival

Sold: June 17, 2017

Value: $60,000

Bottom Line: Northwood Tornado Vase

Tornado carnival glass vase

Hooked on Carnival

A dramatically curved vase intended to evoke the feeling of a tornado, the Northwood Tornado vase is made of a brilliant, bright cobalt blue color.

This particular vase was once part of the record-breaking Engel collection and has changed hands multiple times.

3. Northwood Peacock Vaseline Bowl

Northwood Peacock Vaseline Bowl

Hooked on Carnival

Sold: Aug. 24, 2019

Value: $66,000

Bottom Line: Northwood Peacock Vaseline Bowl

Peacock bowl

Hooked on Carnival

A luminous yellow that glows in the dark, this collectible bowl comes with an incredibly intricate design and the constant feeling that you’re forgetting something (such as getting screened for cancer).

There are very few pieces like this one still out there.

2. Northwood Wisteria Vase in Emerald Green

Northwood Wisteria Vase in Emerald Green

Hooked on Carnival

Sold: Oct. 27, 2018

Value: $140,000

Bottom Line: Northwood Wisteria Vase in Emerald Green

Expensive carnival glass vase

Hooked on Carnival

This vase is nearly more lime green than emerald green — but it still commands emerald prices.

The pitcher mold is made out of bright, green transparent glass with a reddish-brown wash over it.

It is one of the most valuable Northwoods Whimsy items available today.

1. Millersburg People’s Vase in Blue

Millersburg People’s Vase in Blue

Hooked on Carnival

Sold: June 16, 2018

Value: $155,000

Bottom Line: Millersburg People’s Vase in Blue

Blue vase

Hooked on Carnival

This vase is considered the quintessential carnival glass antique, with a glowing cobalt blue backdrop and a multicolored coating. The People’s Vase is presently in the Millersburg Glass Museum, purchased by its director.

Millersburg Glass was commissioned to make a total of 10 People’s Vases in 1910 for the Netherlands’ royal family. Only eight of these vases are known to have survived. The other two are believed to have been destroyed.

What Makes Carnival Glass Valuable?

Carnival Glass Vase

Carnival glass is a beautiful and unique type of glassware that was popular in the early 1900s. Today, it is highly sought-after by collectors and can be quite valuable. But there’s a lot of Carnival glass out there. Tons and tons of it. Most of it is only worth around $20 to $200.

One of the most important factors is the condition of the piece. Carnival glass that is in excellent condition with no chips or cracks will be worth more. This is rare. They are, after all, glass pieces that could be 100 years old. The color of the glass also plays a role in value. Pieces that are a deep, rich color will be worth more.

The type of carnival glass also affects value. Some of the most valuable pieces are those that were made by well-known manufacturers such as Fenton or Northwood. Pieces that are rare or one-of-a-kind will also be worth more. And generally the older the piece is, the more it’s worth. Collectors want to see “early” carnival glass pieces.

Of course, appearance also does matter. A particularly beautiful piece is likely to fetch more, although we can see with the Cleveland Memorial Souvenir Ashtray that isn’t always true.

What Is the Rarest Color of Carnival Glass?

Good Luck Carnival Glass Bowl

While there are many beautiful colors of carnival glass, some are rarer than others. One of the rarest and most valuable colors is purple. Other rare colors include red, orange and yellow.

These colors are less common because they were difficult to produce during the time period when carnival glass was made. Ironically, many collectibles in “less favored” colors become more sought-after and valuable over time.

How Can You Identify Real Carnival Glass?

Fenton Carnival Glass Bowl

There are a few ways that you can tell if a piece of carnival glass is real or fake. One way is to look for the mark of the manufacturer. Many manufacturers of carnival glass put their mark on the bottom of the piece. Fenton and Northwood are two of the most prized manufacturers, but there were many more.

“Real” carnival glass is still being made. Generally, you want to know whether it’s vintage. Vintage carnival glass comes with a few indicators. Notably, the sheen is actually a little worse in older pieces. Older pieces will usually not have a shine on the bottom but in the visible areas.

If your piece is vibrant throughout, it’s an indicator that it’s newer rather than older.

Is Depression Glass the Same as Carnival Glass?

Depression glass

Carnival glass and depression glass are often confused because they are both types of glassware that were popular during the early 1900s. However, they are actually quite different.

Depression glass is mass-produced and can be found for relatively low prices. Carnival glass, on the other hand, is more rare and valuable and was occasionally produced for one-off events.

Compared to carnival glass, depression glass remains cheap. Even the most expensive sets are only around $200.

×

Home Page Career Wealth Real Estate Collectibles Business View From The TopAbout Us Terms of Service Privacy Policy Advertise Contact Us Do Not Sell My Personal InfoAlways Pets Big Edition FamilyMinded Far & Wide Stadium Talk Work + Money

© 2024 Big Edition, Inc.

Collectors Weekly

Exactly what is carnival glass? You’ve likely seen it (or maybe even collected it) and not realized it. Carnival glass is a specific type of pressed glass that has an oil-like sheen to its surface. Popular in the 1920s, it’s still collected today.

Carnival glass started as a low-end imitation of more expensive glass-blowing techniques. Then it became a collectible itself. Most antique carnival glass is worth a few hundred dollars. But the rarest pieces are worth thousands.

25. Northwood Electric Blue Carnival Bowl

Northwood Electric Blue Carnival Bowl

Live Auctioneers

Sold: April 22, 2012

Value: $1,400

Bottom Line: Northwood Electric Blue Carnival Bowl

Electric blue valuable carnival glass

Live Auctioneers

A brilliant bowl with a scalloped edge and matte glaze, this bowl is designed to be reminiscent of a wicker basket filled with flowers.

This is an excellent example of Northwood’s aesthetic and the “electric blue” color, just slightly brighter than dark cobalt.

24. Imperial Electric Purple Carnival Glass Plate

Imperial Electric Purple Carnival Glass Plate

Live Auctioneers

Sold: July 30, 2005

Value: $1,500

Bottom Line: Imperial Electric Purple Carnival Glass Plate

Back of valuable glass bowl

Live Auctioneers

Not all carnival glass was made by Millersburg, Northwood, or Fenton. Imperial made this electric purple plate.

It has an extraordinarily unique design: a pastoral setting with a classically influenced border.